Solar developer’s lawful wrangling attracts praise, criticism

Thomas Melone is president of a Connecticut solar company. He is also a lawyer. And amongst the two, observers say, he is one thing of an enigma. 

As head of Allco Renewable Electricity, Melone claims his company’s corporate mission is to beat the devastating impacts of local climate modify. But he’s also submitted several lawsuits challenging various states’ thoroughly clean electricity plans.

He most just lately built information by suing in federal court to have approvals overturned for Winery Wind — poised to be the country’s initially utility-scale offshore wind farm — citing, among the other points, potential problems to the industrial fishing business. 

And even though he views it as his career to obstacle regulations or policies that limit photo voltaic advancement, the company’s litigious observe document is executing hurt to the industry’s status, some critics say. The Vermont Office of Community Services at the time accused Melone of using “a scorched earth approach” in a proceeding before the General public Utility Fee.

“He is giving solar a seriously lousy title he’s turning people in opposition to solar,” said Annette Smith. In her position as govt director for Vermonters for a Clean up Surroundings, Smith has challenged several photo voltaic tasks herself and been important of Melone’s actions. “You’ve received to do the job with persons. He’s coming in and slugging and building enemies. It is a incredibly weird business enterprise design.”

Melone does not usually acquire in court docket, but that does not seem to be to discourage him. A seasoned attorney who formerly labored in tax legislation and structured finance, Melone states the firm is just working out its legal rights, and is on a mission to help decarbonize the electricity sector as promptly as probable. Expanding solar use, he says, is the very best way to do that. 

“Putting renewable electricity on land makes additional American work opportunities, does not set business fisheries out of organization, is much more protected from an electrical grid viewpoint, and does not occur with all the environmental dangers of offshore wind,” he reported in an e-mail exchange. 

Prior to opposing Winery Wind (and the deserted Cape Wind project prior to that), nevertheless, Melone’s business created an unsuccessful bid of its own to build the country’s to start with offshore wind farm off of Rhode Island.

Melone has also filed a petition objecting to the 650-megawatt pure gas plant planned for Killingly, Connecticut. And he sued the U.S. Forest Assistance around its approvals of the now-lifeless Northern Go transmission line that was proposed to provide hydroelectric ability to New England from Quebec. 

More not too long ago, he gained intervenor standing in a proceeding prior to the Connecticut Siting Council for acceptance of a 9.66-megawatt purely natural gasoline-run gas mobile ability plant in the city of Bridgeport. In filings to the council, Melone argues the fuel mobile will further more deteriorate air high quality in the city’s South Stop, an space with higher asthma charges, and will serve to displace “true renewable power projects” like photo voltaic. As portion of the discovery procedure, he introduced the electric power plant’s developer, NuPower, with 15 pages of in depth concerns. 

For Joe Provey, a home-owner who is intervening on behalf of community inhabitants who see the project as a detriment, the sudden emergence of a lawfully expert ally in the continuing came as a pleasurable shock. 

Though he understands Melone has “his very own agenda,” Provey reported, “I variety of perceive him as a white knight.” 

A trail of assignments, lawsuits

Melone, 63, is a wealthy gentleman. He has numerous properties, which include one particular on the island of Martha’s Vineyard, where by he also funded the improvement of a carrying out arts and studio compound. In his unsuccessful 2010 charm of Cape Wind, which was to be created in Nantucket Seem, he argued that the challenge would negatively affect the viewscape from his Edgartown summertime home and minimize his home worth. 

Just before pursuing photo voltaic progress, Melone arranged tax-based mostly financing for these products as railcars, aircraft, and ability plants. He suggests he received into the photo voltaic business following his organization began advising SunEdison on its solar financings. His first task was in Indiana in 2012. Allco and its subsidiaries now have 35 jobs in operation in Connecticut, Massachusetts, Vermont, New Jersey, Ga, California, Indiana and Minnesota.

Melone acknowledges the company’s preceding interest in building offshore wind in Rhode Island. 

Just after then-Gov. Donald Carcieri declared his administration’s dedication to finding an offshore wind farm up and operating in 2006, Allco tried to get a soar on the game by correct absent inquiring the point out for a permit to install machines that would make it possible for it to collect wind info. But the administration required to forged a broader internet and, in 2008, place the project out to bid. 

Allco’s proposal was one particular of 7. The challenge went to Deepwater Wind, and is now the five-turbine Block Island Wind Farm. 

“We were willing to invest in checking out no matter if wind electric power was appropriate in all those places,” Melone claimed. But for the reason that the firm by no means gained a permit for the details selection devices, he reported, it never ever “got to the issue of staying eager to move in advance with really constructing a wind farm.” 

When it will come to his problem to Vineyard Wind, Melone states he’s only “asking for the federal government to do its career and get a challenging search at the implications of the challenge and the facts.”

The lawsuit in U.S. District Court targets five federal businesses, including the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management. It cites 18 counts of their alleged failures to adhere to federal regulation, including the Nationwide Environmental Safety Act. 

Between the allegations are that federal regulators failed to assess the wind turbines’ capability to face up to a Classification 3-or-larger hurricane. Ought to the turbines be ruined in a extreme storm, the release of oil and other contaminants would destroy fishing grounds and endangered species, which involve the North Atlantic suitable whale and the piping plover, Melone argues. 

Acceptance of the undertaking will also effects Melone’s pleasure of the Audio as a boater, in accordance to the complaint, and decrease Allco’s solar enhancement alternatives, as “offshore wind electrical power producers intend to decimate U.S. onshore renewable strength producers in the northeastern United States.” 

“If Allco is profitable,” Melone mentioned, “the authorities will want to conduct the accurate strong critique of the project.”

Hana V. Vizcarra, a personnel lawyer at the Harvard Legislation Faculty Environmental and Energy Legislation Program, explained Melone seems to be “throwing up just about anything and everything he can” in his prolonged grievance. But she thinks he will very likely run into issues persuading the court he has standing to sue as head of Allco. 

“As courts have turn out to be far more conservative, they are inclined to choose a narrower see as to who has standing to make environmental promises,” Vizcarra stated. “The wish to get rid of competitors from other renewable resources does not give you standing.” 

However, she famous that lots of much more lawsuits no question lie ahead for these significant wind tasks. 

“Regardless of the validity of these claims or the chance of results, both the administration and the offshore wind producers have to be nicely-prepared for that,” Vizcarra claimed. 

A Vineyard Wind spokesperson claimed the organization does not comment on pending litigation. 

A spokesperson for G.E. Renewable Power, the maker of the Haliade-X wind turbines to be applied in the project, also declined comment, other than to point out that the know-how just lately received certification verifying that it can face up to typhoon-stage winds. He did not specify what that signifies in conditions of highest wind speeds. 

A litigation ‘all-star’

Connecticut regulators are quite common with Melone’s title. Allco sued the point out in federal courtroom three occasions in between 2013 and 2016, just about every time challenging the state’s renewable vitality procurement plan. Following the claims were dismissed, Allco appealed to no avail. 

Ari Peskoe, director of the energy law initiative at Harvard Legislation, tracks problems to point out clear vitality policy on his Point out Electrical power Undertaking web site. Allco has filed so many these kinds of challenges Peskoe considers the firm an “all-star” on the site. 

In the scenario that commenced the series of Connecticut satisfies, Melone was in essence “a disappointed bidder” who hadn’t been picked by the Department of Electricity and Environmental Safety in a ask for for proposals for renewable electricity assignments, Peskoe claimed. 

“So he made the decision he was heading to try to invalidate the total system,” he stated.

Robert Klee, then the commissioner of the condition Section of Strength and Environmental Security, was the named defendant in the conditions. Now a lecturer at the Yale School of the Ecosystem and Yale Law Faculty, Klee declined to remark.

Melone has also had some successes in his condition coverage troubles, probably most notably in California. In 2017, following a number of many years of litigation, the U.S. District Court in the Northern District of California agreed with Allco that a condition renewable electrical power procurement system was in violation of the Community Utility Regulatory Insurance policies Act, identified as PURPA. He gained a comparable challenge in Massachusetts. 

Melone’s authorized battles have most likely been fought most fiercely in Vermont, where Smith, the environmental activist, claims he has submitted about a dozen appeals in point out Supreme Court docket above numerous challenges.

Most existing litigation is connected to his several years-extended initiatives to acquire two photo voltaic initiatives totaling 4 megawatts on 27 acres of forested land in Bennington. Owners in a neighboring household progress have opposed the options. And there have been prolonged quarrels as to regardless of whether the two jobs are fundamentally one particular, which would violate the 2.2-megawatt cap in the plan under which Melone obtained his electrical power contracts.

The undertaking proposals have bounced again and forth amongst the General public Utilities Commission and the courts, as Melone has regularly challenged their denials. 

Final calendar year, he filed a federal lawsuit in opposition to utility commissioners and Gov. Phil Scott, alleging that commissioners unfairly bowed to pressure from lawmakers and neighborhood opponents to reject his jobs. In a response, the condition legal professional general’s business said the complaint evinces the company’s “disgruntlement with staying issue to Vermont legislation.” The situation was dismissed in March.

Melone has also sued a social media critic in Bennington for defamation. 

Regulators recently issued an injunction after concluding that Allco and its affiliate marketers experienced executed some unauthorized clearing on the Bennington web-site. In a temporary supporting the injunction, an lawyer for the point out Agency of All-natural Methods explained that rare crops and experienced trees experienced been wrecked by the clearing. 

“The developer has persistently and willfully refused to abide by the commission’s necessities in these proceedings,” the attorney wrote. “The developer’s actions have imposed unwanted and inappropriate burdens on the get-togethers and their counsel in dealing with and responding to the developer’s unauthorized, unacceptable and persistent carry out.” 

Melone has appealed the injunction.

He denies that he is using a “scorched earth” tactic to photo voltaic growth in Vermont. The functions that use the time period are leveling “baseless attacks” relatively than addressing the material of the difficulties, he states.

Acknowledging that most photo voltaic developers can’t manage these sustained lawful filings, Melone claims it is an benefit to be in a position to manage cases generally in-home. But he also thinks, like Provey, that there is a white knight part to his prodigious lawful activities. 

“If I was not an legal professional,” he stated, “we wouldn’t be in a position to help the people in Bridgeport’s environmental justice group stop the gas cell plant.” As if his plate wasn’t complete ample, he’s bought a further gas mobile venture in his sights. FuelCell Vitality just filed a petition for an 8.4-megawatt facility in Hartford, Connecticut. Melone suggests he absolutely expects Allco will intervene.